{"entities":[{"id":"bender-koller-2020-climbing-nlu","name":"Climbing towards NLU: On Meaning, Form, and Understanding in the Age of Data","shortName":"Bender and Koller, Climbing towards NLU (2020)","type":"document"},{"id":"llms-lack-agency","name":"Language models lack agency or understanding","type":"concept","proposition":{"code":"R14","criterion":"Large language models lack goals, agency or understanding of their own, being systems that model or reproduce text.","terms":["stochastic parrots","autocomplete","agency"]}},{"id":"piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","name":"Meaning without reference in large language models","type":"document","subtype":"Preprint","description":"A preprint by Steven T. Piantadosi and Felix Hill, arXiv preprint 2208.02957, dated 5 August 2022. arXiv v1, 5 August 2022.","sourceIds":["source-rd-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference"]}],"claims":[{"id":"rd-r14-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","subject":"piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","predicate":"contests_proposition","object":{"kind":"entity","entityId":"llms-lack-agency"},"topic":"ideas","statement":"Piantadosi and Hill's paper of August 2022 argues, against the view that LLMs possess no meaning, that they likely capture important aspects of meaning through conceptual role, which can only be judged by examining how their internal states relate.","time":{"kind":"event","date":"2022-08-05","basis":"publication","note":"Date of the arXiv v1 submission."},"derivation":"explicit","resolution":"supported","editorialState":"seed","evidenceIds":["evidence-rd-r14-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference-1","evidence-rd-r14-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference-2"],"attributes":{"thought":{"roles":["contesting","earliest-located"],"register":"nonfiction","engagement":{"kind":"engages-premise","rationale":"It disputes the premise that a model trained on text alone, without reference to the world, cannot acquire meaning."}}}},{"id":"rd-reply-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference-to-bender-koller-2020-climbing-nlu","subject":"piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","predicate":"cites","object":{"kind":"entity","entityId":"bender-koller-2020-climbing-nlu"},"topic":"ideas","statement":"Piantadosi and Hill's paper of August 2022 replies to Bender and Koller's paper of 2020, which it names and whose octopus test it discusses.","time":{"kind":"event","date":"2022-08-05","basis":"publication","note":"Date of the arXiv v1 submission."},"derivation":"explicit","resolution":"supported","editorialState":"seed","evidenceIds":["evidence-rd-reply-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference-to-bender-koller-2020-climbing-nlu-1"]}],"sources":[{"id":"source-rd-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","documentId":"piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","title":"Meaning without reference in large language models","authors":["Steven T. Piantadosi","Felix Hill"],"publisher":"arXiv preprint 2208.02957","publicationDate":"2022-08-05","version":"Retrieved for the candidate pack on 2026-10-29 (SHA-256 2696790ec6304619048169129619e6da71cb6617a144ea5379ebefa937bb0696). arXiv v1 of 5 August 2022. The cross-family check retrieved it again on 2026-10-31, with the same bytes.","evidenceUrl":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2208.02957v1","language":"en"}],"evidence":[{"id":"evidence-rd-r14-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference-1","claimId":"rd-r14-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","sourceId":"source-rd-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","sourceRole":"primary","support":"supports","verification":"machine_checked","retrievalRoute":"direct"},{"id":"evidence-rd-r14-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference-2","claimId":"rd-r14-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","sourceId":"source-rd-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","support":"supports","verification":"machine_checked","retrievalRoute":"direct"},{"id":"evidence-rd-reply-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference-to-bender-koller-2020-climbing-nlu-1","claimId":"rd-reply-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference-to-bender-koller-2020-climbing-nlu","sourceId":"source-rd-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","sourceRole":"primary","support":"supports","verification":"machine_checked","retrievalRoute":"direct"}],"at":{"entities":[1789,1864,1896],"claims":[5279,5353],"sources":[1793],"evidence":[7067,7068,7193]},"index":{"byClaim":[["rd-r14-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference",["propositions:risk-debate"]]],"marks":[["piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference",[{"collectionId":"risk-debate","propositionId":"llms-lack-agency","claimId":"rd-r14-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference","text":"Earliest located text contesting R14 Language models lack agency or understanding in Arguments about catastrophic risk from advanced AI"}]]],"chronicle":{"years":[{"year":1863,"topics":{"ideas":5},"stated":0},{"year":1865,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1872,"topics":{"ideas":7},"stated":0},{"year":1943,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1947,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1950,"topics":{"ideas":7},"stated":0},{"year":1951,"topics":{"ideas":5},"stated":0},{"year":1952,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1955,"topics":{"ideas":31},"stated":0},{"year":1956,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1957,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1958,"topics":{"ideas":3},"stated":0},{"year":1959,"topics":{"ideas":6},"stated":0},{"year":1960,"topics":{"ideas":11},"stated":0},{"year":1961,"topics":{"ideas":10},"stated":0},{"year":1965,"topics":{"ideas":8},"stated":0},{"year":1966,"topics":{"ideas":20},"stated":0},{"year":1968,"topics":{"ideas":5},"stated":0},{"year":1969,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1971,"topics":{"ideas":4},"stated":0},{"year":1972,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1973,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1974,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1975,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1976,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1977,"topics":{"people":2,"ideas":8},"stated":0},{"year":1979,"topics":{"ideas":4},"stated":0},{"year":1980,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1981,"topics":{"people":2},"stated":0},{"year":1982,"topics":{"ideas":4},"stated":0},{"year":1983,"topics":{"ideas":4},"stated":0},{"year":1984,"topics":{"ideas":21},"stated":0},{"year":1985,"topics":{"ideas":9},"stated":0},{"year":1986,"topics":{"ideas":18},"stated":0},{"year":1987,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1988,"topics":{"ideas":6},"stated":0},{"year":1989,"topics":{"ideas":8},"stated":0},{"year":1990,"topics":{"ideas":5},"stated":0},{"year":1991,"topics":{"ideas":11},"stated":0},{"year":1992,"topics":{"ideas":9},"stated":0},{"year":1993,"topics":{"ideas":14,"people":3},"stated":0},{"year":1994,"topics":{"ideas":14},"stated":0},{"year":1995,"topics":{"ideas":10,"people":1},"stated":0},{"year":1996,"topics":{"ideas":71},"stated":0},{"year":1997,"topics":{"ideas":12},"stated":0},{"year":1998,"topics":{"ideas":49},"stated":0},{"year":1999,"topics":{"ideas":27,"people":1,"institutions":1},"stated":0},{"year":2000,"topics":{"ideas":62},"stated":0},{"year":2001,"topics":{"ideas":39},"stated":0},{"year":2002,"topics":{"ideas":30},"stated":0},{"year":2003,"topics":{"ideas":8},"stated":0},{"year":2004,"topics":{"ideas":12,"people":3},"stated":0},{"year":2005,"topics":{"ideas":10,"people":1},"stated":0},{"year":2006,"topics":{"ideas":26,"people":1},"stated":0},{"year":2007,"topics":{"ideas":20},"stated":0},{"year":2008,"topics":{"ideas":57,"people":3,"institutions":1},"stated":0},{"year":2009,"topics":{"ideas":10,"people":1},"stated":0},{"year":2010,"topics":{"people":3,"ideas":11,"institutions":1,"governance":4},"stated":0},{"year":2011,"topics":{"people":3,"ideas":7,"institutions":2},"stated":0},{"year":2012,"topics":{"people":4,"ideas":17,"institutions":2},"stated":0},{"year":2013,"topics":{"ideas":46,"people":4,"institutions":2,"capital":1},"stated":0},{"year":2014,"topics":{"institutions":2,"ideas":54,"people":5},"stated":0},{"year":2015,"topics":{"people":22,"ideas":122,"institutions":3,"capital":1},"stated":0},{"year":2016,"topics":{"ideas":88,"people":2},"stated":0},{"year":2017,"topics":{"people":16,"institutions":2,"ideas":128,"governance":2},"stated":0},{"year":2018,"topics":{"people":8,"ideas":158,"institutions":8,"governance":1},"stated":0},{"year":2019,"topics":{"capital":1,"compute":1,"people":10,"governance":19,"ideas":175,"institutions":4},"stated":0},{"year":2020,"topics":{"people":6,"ideas":98,"institutions":1,"governance":2},"stated":0},{"year":2021,"topics":{"people":27,"ideas":177,"compute":1,"institutions":23,"governance":4,"capital":6},"stated":0},{"year":2022,"topics":{"people":15,"ideas":217,"institutions":6,"governance":3,"compute":2,"capital":1},"stated":0},{"year":2023,"topics":{"capital":5,"compute":7,"institutions":23,"people":51,"governance":179,"ideas":389},"stated":0},{"year":2024,"topics":{"capital":12,"compute":19,"governance":282,"people":80,"ideas":178,"institutions":28},"stated":1},{"year":2025,"topics":{"governance":547,"compute":69,"capital":34,"people":90,"institutions":18,"ideas":178},"stated":7},{"year":2026,"topics":{"governance":442,"capital":8,"compute":32,"institutions":21,"ideas":91,"people":107},"stated":19},{"year":2027,"topics":{},"stated":9},{"year":2028,"topics":{},"stated":6},{"year":2029,"topics":{},"stated":3},{"year":2030,"topics":{},"stated":3},{"year":2032,"topics":{},"stated":2},{"year":2035,"topics":{},"stated":2},{"year":2039,"topics":{},"stated":1},{"year":2042,"topics":{},"stated":1},{"year":2050,"topics":{},"stated":1}],"scheduled":[],"statedBy":[]},"collections":[{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"superintelligence"},"title":"Propositions about superintelligence, 1863–2022","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"risk-debate"},"title":"Arguments about catastrophic risk from advanced AI","claimIds":["rd-r14-piantadosi-hill-2022-meaning-without-reference"],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"yudkowsky-arguments"},"title":"Eliezer Yudkowsky’s arguments on common claims about AI, 1996–2026","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"economics-of-machine-intelligence"},"title":"Economics of machine intelligence","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"orbital-compute-arguments"},"title":"Arguments about compute in orbit","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"ai-bio-arguments"},"title":"Arguments about AI and biological risk","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"ai-in-science"},"title":"AI in science","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"documents"},"title":"Frontier safety frameworks","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"compare","id":"frontier-safety-frameworks"},"title":"Compare frameworks","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"control","id":"openai"},"title":"OpenAI’s control structure, 2015–2026","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"control","id":"anthropic"},"title":"Anthropic’s control structure, 2021–2026","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"commitments"},"title":"External commitments and obligations","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"question","id":"frameworks-to-obligations"},"title":"Frameworks, commitments and legal obligations, 2023–2026","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"reading"},"title":"Founding and early leadership","claimIds":[]}]},"version":"131evrz"}