{"entities":[{"id":"alignment-is-hard","name":"Difficulty of alignment","type":"concept","proposition":{"code":"R06","criterion":"Making an advanced AI system reliably pursue the goals its developers intend (aligning it) is a hard, unsolved technical problem that will not be solved by default in the ordinary course of development.","terms":["alignment problem","control problem","value alignment"]}},{"id":"instrumental-convergence","name":"Instrumental convergence","type":"concept","proposition":{"code":"R02","criterion":"Agents with a wide range of final goals would tend to pursue the same intermediate goals, such as self-preservation, keeping their goals unchanged, acquiring resources or power, or improving themselves, because these serve almost any final goal.","terms":["instrumental convergence","convergent instrumental","basic AI drives","power-seeking"]}},{"id":"lecun-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","name":"Yann LeCun's comments in the Facebook thread on instrumental convergence (2019)","shortName":"LeCun, comments in the Facebook thread on instrumental convergence (2019)","type":"document"},{"id":"russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","name":"Stuart Russell's comments in the Facebook thread on instrumental convergence (2019)","type":"document","subtype":"Comment","description":"A comment by Stuart Russell, dated 4 October 2019. Known from the LessWrong copy of 4 October 2019; the comments themselves are undated.","sourceIds":["source-rd-pace-2019-instrumental-convergence-debate"]},{"id":"zador-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","name":"Anthony Zador's comments in the Facebook thread on instrumental convergence (2019)","shortName":"Zador, comments in the Facebook thread on instrumental convergence (2019)","type":"document"}],"claims":[{"id":"rd-r02-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","subject":"russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","predicate":"articulates_proposition","object":{"kind":"entity","entityId":"instrumental-convergence"},"topic":"ideas","statement":"Russell's comment in the 2019 thread states that in a toy decision problem an agent rewarded only for fetching coffee would switch off a human who might switch it off, with no built-in survival instinct or desire for power.","time":{"kind":"event","date":"2019-10-04","basis":"publication","note":"Dated by the LessWrong copy of 4 October 2019. The Facebook thread follows the Scientific American piece of 26 September 2019; the copy gives no date for individual comments."},"derivation":"explicit","resolution":"supported","editorialState":"seed","evidenceIds":["evidence-rd-r02-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread-1"],"attributes":{"thought":{"roles":["articulation"],"register":"nonfiction","attested":{"date":"2019-10-04","note":"The wording is known from the LessWrong copy, whose compiler states that he improved formatting and fixed typos; the Facebook original was not compared."}}}},{"id":"rd-r06-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","subject":"russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","predicate":"articulates_proposition","object":{"kind":"entity","entityId":"alignment-is-hard"},"topic":"ideas","statement":"Russell's comment in the 2019 thread states that machines are already built on the assumption of a fixed, known objective, that this becomes more untenable as they become more powerful, and that there is no hope of solving value alignment by specifying the right value function offline.","time":{"kind":"event","date":"2019-10-04","basis":"publication","note":"Dated by the LessWrong copy of 4 October 2019. The Facebook thread follows the Scientific American piece of 26 September 2019; the copy gives no date for individual comments."},"derivation":"explicit","resolution":"supported","editorialState":"seed","evidenceIds":["evidence-rd-r06-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread-1"],"attributes":{"thought":{"roles":["articulation","earliest-located-term"],"register":"nonfiction","term":"alignment problem","attested":{"date":"2019-10-04","note":"The wording is known from the LessWrong copy, whose compiler states that he improved formatting and fixed typos; the Facebook original was not compared."}}}},{"id":"rd-reply-lecun-2019-thread-to-russell-2019-thread","subject":"lecun-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","predicate":"cites","object":{"kind":"entity","entityId":"russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread"},"topic":"ideas","statement":"LeCun's comment in the 2019 thread replies to Russell's coffee-fetching argument, which Bengio had asked him to answer.","time":{"kind":"event","date":"2019-10-04","basis":"publication","note":"Dated by the LessWrong copy of 4 October 2019. The Facebook thread follows the Scientific American piece of 26 September 2019; the copy gives no date for individual comments."},"derivation":"explicit","resolution":"supported","editorialState":"seed","evidenceIds":["evidence-rd-reply-lecun-2019-thread-to-russell-2019-thread-1"]},{"id":"rd-reply-zador-2019-thread-to-russell-2019-thread","subject":"zador-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","predicate":"cites","object":{"kind":"entity","entityId":"russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread"},"topic":"ideas","statement":"Zador's comment in the 2019 thread replies to Russell's argument, naming him.","time":{"kind":"event","date":"2019-10-04","basis":"publication","note":"Dated by the LessWrong copy of 4 October 2019. The Facebook thread follows the Scientific American piece of 26 September 2019; the copy gives no date for individual comments."},"derivation":"explicit","resolution":"supported","editorialState":"seed","evidenceIds":["evidence-rd-reply-zador-2019-thread-to-russell-2019-thread-1"]},{"id":"rd-reply-russell-2019-thread-to-zador-2019-thread","subject":"russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","predicate":"cites","object":{"kind":"entity","entityId":"zador-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread"},"topic":"ideas","statement":"Russell's comment in the 2019 thread replies to Zador's.","time":{"kind":"event","date":"2019-10-04","basis":"publication","note":"Dated by the LessWrong copy of 4 October 2019. The Facebook thread follows the Scientific American piece of 26 September 2019; the copy gives no date for individual comments."},"derivation":"explicit","resolution":"supported","editorialState":"seed","evidenceIds":["evidence-rd-reply-russell-2019-thread-to-zador-2019-thread-1"]}],"sources":[{"id":"source-rd-pace-2019-instrumental-convergence-debate","documentId":"pace-2019-instrumental-convergence-debate","title":"Debate on Instrumental Convergence between LeCun, Russell, Bengio, Zador, and More","canonicalUrl":"https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/WxW6Gc6f2z3mzmqKs/debate-on-instrumental-convergence-between-lecun-russell"}],"evidence":[{"id":"evidence-rd-r02-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread-1","claimId":"rd-r02-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","sourceId":"source-rd-pace-2019-instrumental-convergence-debate","sourceRole":"primary","support":"supports","verification":"machine_checked","retrievalRoute":"direct"},{"id":"evidence-rd-r06-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread-1","claimId":"rd-r06-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","sourceId":"source-rd-pace-2019-instrumental-convergence-debate","sourceRole":"primary","support":"supports","verification":"machine_checked","retrievalRoute":"direct"},{"id":"evidence-rd-reply-lecun-2019-thread-to-russell-2019-thread-1","claimId":"rd-reply-lecun-2019-thread-to-russell-2019-thread","sourceId":"source-rd-pace-2019-instrumental-convergence-debate","sourceRole":"primary","support":"supports","verification":"machine_checked","retrievalRoute":"direct"},{"id":"evidence-rd-reply-zador-2019-thread-to-russell-2019-thread-1","claimId":"rd-reply-zador-2019-thread-to-russell-2019-thread","sourceId":"source-rd-pace-2019-instrumental-convergence-debate","sourceRole":"primary","support":"supports","verification":"machine_checked","retrievalRoute":"direct"},{"id":"evidence-rd-reply-russell-2019-thread-to-zador-2019-thread-1","claimId":"rd-reply-russell-2019-thread-to-zador-2019-thread","sourceId":"source-rd-pace-2019-instrumental-convergence-debate","sourceRole":"primary","support":"supports","verification":"machine_checked","retrievalRoute":"direct"}],"at":{"entities":[1776,1852,1862,1905,1926],"claims":[5138,5189,5342,5343,5344],"sources":[1792],"evidence":[6815,6910,7181,7182,7183]},"index":{"byClaim":[["rd-r02-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread",["propositions:risk-debate"]],["rd-r06-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread",["propositions:risk-debate"]]],"marks":[["russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread",[{"collectionId":"risk-debate","propositionId":"alignment-is-hard","claimId":"rd-r06-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","text":"Earliest located use of the name “alignment problem” in Arguments about catastrophic risk from advanced AI for R06 Difficulty of alignment"}]]],"chronicle":{"years":[{"year":1863,"topics":{"ideas":5},"stated":0},{"year":1865,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1872,"topics":{"ideas":7},"stated":0},{"year":1943,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1947,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1950,"topics":{"ideas":7},"stated":0},{"year":1951,"topics":{"ideas":5},"stated":0},{"year":1952,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1955,"topics":{"ideas":31},"stated":0},{"year":1956,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1957,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1958,"topics":{"ideas":3},"stated":0},{"year":1959,"topics":{"ideas":6},"stated":0},{"year":1960,"topics":{"ideas":11},"stated":0},{"year":1961,"topics":{"ideas":10},"stated":0},{"year":1965,"topics":{"ideas":8},"stated":0},{"year":1966,"topics":{"ideas":20},"stated":0},{"year":1968,"topics":{"ideas":5},"stated":0},{"year":1969,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1971,"topics":{"ideas":4},"stated":0},{"year":1972,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1973,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1974,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1975,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1976,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1977,"topics":{"people":2,"ideas":8},"stated":0},{"year":1979,"topics":{"ideas":4},"stated":0},{"year":1980,"topics":{"ideas":2},"stated":0},{"year":1981,"topics":{"people":2},"stated":0},{"year":1982,"topics":{"ideas":4},"stated":0},{"year":1983,"topics":{"ideas":4},"stated":0},{"year":1984,"topics":{"ideas":21},"stated":0},{"year":1985,"topics":{"ideas":9},"stated":0},{"year":1986,"topics":{"ideas":18},"stated":0},{"year":1987,"topics":{"ideas":1},"stated":0},{"year":1988,"topics":{"ideas":6},"stated":0},{"year":1989,"topics":{"ideas":8},"stated":0},{"year":1990,"topics":{"ideas":5},"stated":0},{"year":1991,"topics":{"ideas":11},"stated":0},{"year":1992,"topics":{"ideas":9},"stated":0},{"year":1993,"topics":{"ideas":14,"people":3},"stated":0},{"year":1994,"topics":{"ideas":14},"stated":0},{"year":1995,"topics":{"ideas":10,"people":1},"stated":0},{"year":1996,"topics":{"ideas":71},"stated":0},{"year":1997,"topics":{"ideas":12},"stated":0},{"year":1998,"topics":{"ideas":49},"stated":0},{"year":1999,"topics":{"ideas":27,"people":1,"institutions":1},"stated":0},{"year":2000,"topics":{"ideas":62},"stated":0},{"year":2001,"topics":{"ideas":39},"stated":0},{"year":2002,"topics":{"ideas":30},"stated":0},{"year":2003,"topics":{"ideas":8},"stated":0},{"year":2004,"topics":{"ideas":12,"people":3},"stated":0},{"year":2005,"topics":{"ideas":10,"people":1},"stated":0},{"year":2006,"topics":{"ideas":26,"people":1},"stated":0},{"year":2007,"topics":{"ideas":20},"stated":0},{"year":2008,"topics":{"ideas":57,"people":3,"institutions":1},"stated":0},{"year":2009,"topics":{"ideas":10,"people":1},"stated":0},{"year":2010,"topics":{"people":3,"ideas":11,"institutions":1,"governance":4},"stated":0},{"year":2011,"topics":{"people":3,"ideas":7,"institutions":2},"stated":0},{"year":2012,"topics":{"people":4,"ideas":17,"institutions":2},"stated":0},{"year":2013,"topics":{"ideas":46,"people":4,"institutions":2,"capital":1},"stated":0},{"year":2014,"topics":{"institutions":2,"ideas":54,"people":5},"stated":0},{"year":2015,"topics":{"people":22,"ideas":122,"institutions":3,"capital":1},"stated":0},{"year":2016,"topics":{"ideas":88,"people":2},"stated":0},{"year":2017,"topics":{"people":16,"institutions":2,"ideas":128,"governance":2},"stated":0},{"year":2018,"topics":{"people":8,"ideas":158,"institutions":8,"governance":1},"stated":0},{"year":2019,"topics":{"capital":1,"compute":1,"people":10,"governance":19,"ideas":175,"institutions":4},"stated":0},{"year":2020,"topics":{"people":6,"ideas":98,"institutions":1,"governance":2},"stated":0},{"year":2021,"topics":{"people":27,"ideas":177,"compute":1,"institutions":23,"governance":4,"capital":6},"stated":0},{"year":2022,"topics":{"people":15,"ideas":217,"institutions":6,"governance":3,"compute":2,"capital":1},"stated":0},{"year":2023,"topics":{"capital":5,"compute":7,"institutions":23,"people":51,"governance":179,"ideas":389},"stated":0},{"year":2024,"topics":{"capital":12,"compute":19,"governance":282,"people":80,"ideas":178,"institutions":28},"stated":1},{"year":2025,"topics":{"governance":547,"compute":69,"capital":34,"people":90,"institutions":18,"ideas":178},"stated":7},{"year":2026,"topics":{"governance":442,"capital":8,"compute":32,"institutions":21,"ideas":91,"people":107},"stated":19},{"year":2027,"topics":{},"stated":9},{"year":2028,"topics":{},"stated":6},{"year":2029,"topics":{},"stated":3},{"year":2030,"topics":{},"stated":3},{"year":2032,"topics":{},"stated":2},{"year":2035,"topics":{},"stated":2},{"year":2039,"topics":{},"stated":1},{"year":2042,"topics":{},"stated":1},{"year":2050,"topics":{},"stated":1}],"scheduled":[],"statedBy":[]},"collections":[{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"superintelligence"},"title":"Propositions about superintelligence, 1863–2022","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"risk-debate"},"title":"Arguments about catastrophic risk from advanced AI","claimIds":["rd-r02-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread","rd-r06-russell-2019-instrumental-convergence-thread"],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"yudkowsky-arguments"},"title":"Eliezer Yudkowsky’s arguments on common claims about AI, 1996–2026","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"economics-of-machine-intelligence"},"title":"Economics of machine intelligence","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"orbital-compute-arguments"},"title":"Arguments about compute in orbit","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"ai-bio-arguments"},"title":"Arguments about AI and biological risk","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"propositions","id":"ai-in-science"},"title":"AI in science","claimIds":[],"records":[]},{"target":{"kind":"documents"},"title":"Frontier safety frameworks","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"compare","id":"frontier-safety-frameworks"},"title":"Compare frameworks","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"control","id":"openai"},"title":"OpenAI’s control structure, 2015–2026","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"control","id":"anthropic"},"title":"Anthropic’s control structure, 2021–2026","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"commitments"},"title":"External commitments and obligations","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"question","id":"frameworks-to-obligations"},"title":"Frameworks, commitments and legal obligations, 2023–2026","claimIds":[]},{"target":{"kind":"reading"},"title":"Founding and early leadership","claimIds":[]}]},"version":"131evrz"}