Found and cross-checked by machines · How this works →

Propositions by author · 10 propositions · 151 records · 66 texts

Machine succession, scale and acceleration: propositions in located texts, 1979–2026

Which located texts, from 1979 to 2026, state, contest or bear on ten propositions about machine intelligence: that machines succeed humans, that this would be acceptable, that minds move into machines, that building such machines brings conflict, that machine intelligence vastly exceeds human intelligence, that capital is itself a machine intelligence, that intelligence is its own end, that development should be accelerated, and that machine intelligence is a cosmic process that spreads beyond Earth? For each proposition, which text is the earliest located?

Each row is one text’s stance on one proposition, as a stored record states it: articulates, contests or bears on. A stance belongs to the text, not to its author. Rows are in date order, which records no influence between texts. Authors appear as the texts’ own bylines print them, pseudonyms included. “Earliest located” marks only a text the collection’s records name as the earliest the searches found.

Download the stances shown (CSV)

WA · Machine intelligence and the human succession

W01 Machines succeed humans as the leading intelligence

  1. ArticulatesHans MoravecToday’s Computers, Intelligent Machines and Our Future1979-02 · published · wording attested 2001-07-10 · claimed 1976-07-21Inspect the record ↗
  2. Articulates · Earliest locatedHugo de GarisWhat If AI Succeeds? The Rise of the Twenty-First Century Artilect1989 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  3. Articulates · Earliest located use of the name “post-biological”Hans MoravecHuman Culture—A Genetic Takeover Underway1989 · published · wording attested 2001-03-06 · claimed 1988-07Inspect the record ↗
  4. ArticulatesHans MoravecThe Robot as Liberation from Human Nature1989-12 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31 · claimed 1989-03Inspect the record ↗
  5. ArticulatesHans MoravecThe Universal Robot1991-07 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  6. ArticulatesNick LandCircuitries1992-10 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  7. ArticulatesHans MoravecThe Age of Robots1993-06 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  8. ArticulatesVernor VingeThe Coming Technological Singularity: How to Survive in the Post-Human Era1993-12 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  9. ArticulatesMarvin L. MinskyWill Robots Inherit the Earth?1994-10 · published · wording attested 1997-01-02Inspect the record ↗
  10. Bears onNick LandMeltdown1997 · published · wording attested 2004-02-03Inspect the record ↗
  11. ArticulatesHans MoravecRise of the Robots1999-12 · published · wording attested 2001-03-30Inspect the record ↗
  12. Contests · Earliest locatedJaron LanierOne Half a Manifesto2000-11-10 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  13. ArticulatesHans MoravecRobots, Re-Evolving Mind2000-12 · published · wording attested 2001-06-27Inspect the record ↗
  14. ArticulatesRay KurzweilThe Law of Accelerating Returns2001-03-07 · published · wording attested 2025-01-01Inspect the record ↗
  15. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe Artilect War: Cosmists vs. Terrans2005 · published · wording attested 2014-03-17Inspect the record ↗
  16. ArticulatesKevin WarwickForeword to The Artilect War2005 · published · wording attested 2014-03-17Inspect the record ↗
  17. Bears on · Relay of another authorAlex Williams; Nick Srnicek#ACCELERATE MANIFESTO for an Accelerationist Politics2013-05-14 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  18. ArticulatesRich SuttonThe AI Singularity: Prospects for Digital Immortality2013-12-03Inspect the record ↗
  19. ContestsDaniel C. DennettThe Singularity—an Urban Legend?2015 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  20. ContestsSteven PinkerThinking Does Not Imply Subjugating2015 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  21. ArticulatesMartin ReesOrganic Intelligence Has No Long-Term Future2015 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  22. ArticulatesHugo de GarisHow Will the Artilect War Start?2015-08-10 · published · claimed 2014-01Inspect the record ↗
  23. ArticulatesRich SuttonAI Succession2023-07-07Inspect the record ↗
  24. ArticulatesDaniel FaggellaA Worthy Successor – The Purpose of AGI2023-11-24 · published · wording attested 2026-10-15Inspect the record ↗
  25. ArticulatesVitalik ButerinMy techno-optimism2023-11-27 · publishedInspect the record ↗

W02 Succession by machines would be acceptable or desirable

  1. ArticulatesHans MoravecToday’s Computers, Intelligent Machines and Our Future1979-02 · published · wording attested 2001-07-10 · claimed 1976-07-21Inspect the record ↗
  2. Bears onHugo de GarisWhat If AI Succeeds? The Rise of the Twenty-First Century Artilect1989 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  3. ArticulatesHans MoravecHuman Culture—A Genetic Takeover Underway1989 · published · wording attested 2001-03-06 · claimed 1988-07Inspect the record ↗
  4. Bears onHugo de GarisThe 21st Century Artilect: Moral Dilemmas Concerning the Ultra Intelligent Machine1990 · published · wording attested 1999-03-20 · claimed 1989-05Inspect the record ↗
  5. Articulates · Earliest located use of the name “worthy successor”Hans MoravecThe Universal Robot1991-07 · published · wording attested 1999-02-09Inspect the record ↗
  6. Bears onNick LandCircuitries1992-10 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  7. Articulates · Earliest locatedMarvin L. MinskyWill Robots Inherit the Earth?1994-10 · published · wording attested 1997-01-02Inspect the record ↗
  8. Contests · Earliest locatedBill JoyWhy the Future Doesn't Need Us2000-04 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  9. ArticulatesHans MoravecRobots, Re-Evolving Mind2000-12 · published · wording attested 2001-06-27Inspect the record ↗
  10. ArticulatesHugo de GarisBuilding Gods or Building Our Potential Exterminators?2001-02-26 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  11. Bears onRay KurzweilThe Law of Accelerating Returns2001-03-07 · published · wording attested 2025-01-01Inspect the record ↗
  12. ContestsNick BostromThe Future of Human Evolution2004 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  13. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe Artilect War: Cosmists vs. Terrans2005 · published · wording attested 2014-03-17Inspect the record ↗
  14. Bears onDavid J. ChalmersThe Singularity: A Philosophical Analysis2010 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  15. ArticulatesHugo de Garis; Ben GoertzelSeeking the Sputnik of AGI2011-03-30 · published · wording attested 2015Inspect the record ↗
  16. ContestsHugo de Garis; Ben GoertzelSeeking the Sputnik of AGI2011-03-30 · published · wording attested 2015Inspect the record ↗
  17. Bears one/accEffective Accelerationism — e/acc2022-06-01 · published · wording attested 2022-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  18. ArticulatesBeff Jezos; bayesNotes on e/acc principles and tenets2022-07-10 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  19. Contestse/accwhat the f* is e/acc2022-12-26 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  20. ArticulatesRich SuttonAI Succession2023-07-07Inspect the record ↗
  21. ArticulatesDaniel FaggellaA Worthy Successor – The Purpose of AGI2023-11-24 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  22. ContestsVitalik ButerinMy techno-optimism2023-11-27 · publishedInspect the record ↗

W03 Human minds transferred into machines

  1. ArticulatesHans MoravecToday’s Computers, Intelligent Machines and Our Future1979-02 · published · wording attested 2001-07-10 · claimed 1976-07-21Inspect the record ↗
  2. Bears onHugo de GarisWhat If AI Succeeds? The Rise of the Twenty-First Century Artilect1989 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  3. ArticulatesHans MoravecAfter Life1989-09 · published · wording attested 1999-11-10Inspect the record ↗
  4. ArticulatesHans MoravecThe Robot as Liberation from Human Nature1989-12 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31 · claimed 1989-03Inspect the record ↗
  5. ArticulatesHans MoravecPigs in Cyberspace1992 · published · wording attested 1999-04-27Inspect the record ↗
  6. ArticulatesFrederik Pohl; Hans MoravecSouls in Silicon1993-11 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  7. Articulates · Earliest located use of the name “upload”Robin HansonIf Uploads Come First: The Crack of a Future Dawn1994 · published · wording attested 1998-02-20Inspect the record ↗
  8. Articulates · Earliest locatedMarvin L. MinskyWill Robots Inherit the Earth?1994-10 · published · wording attested 1997-01-02Inspect the record ↗
  9. Contests · Earliest locatedColin McGinnHello, HAL1999-01-03 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  10. ContestsJohn R. SearleI Married a Computer1999-04-08 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  11. ContestsBill JoyWhy the Future Doesn't Need Us2000-04 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  12. ArticulatesRay KurzweilThe Law of Accelerating Returns2001-03-07 · published · wording attested 2025-01-01Inspect the record ↗
  13. ArticulatesNick BostromThe Transhumanist FAQ, Version 2.12003 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  14. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe Artilect War: Cosmists vs. Terrans2005 · published · wording attested 2014-03-17Inspect the record ↗
  15. Bears onKevin WarwickForeword to The Artilect War2005 · published · wording attested 2014-03-17Inspect the record ↗
  16. Bears onHugo de GarisThe Coming Artilect War2009-06-22 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  17. ArticulatesDavid J. ChalmersThe Singularity: A Philosophical Analysis2010 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  18. ArticulatesHugo de Garis; Ben GoertzelSeeking the Sputnik of AGI2011-03-30 · published · wording attested 2015Inspect the record ↗
  19. ArticulatesRich SuttonThe AI Singularity: Prospects for Digital Immortality2013-12-03Inspect the record ↗
  20. ArticulatesFrank TiplerAI's Will Save Us All2015 · publishedInspect the record ↗

W04 Conflict over building superhuman machines

  1. Articulates · Earliest located · Earliest located use of the name “Cosmist”Hugo de GarisWhat If AI Succeeds? The Rise of the Twenty-First Century Artilect1989 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  2. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe 21st Century Artilect: Moral Dilemmas Concerning the Ultra Intelligent Machine1990 · published · wording attested 1999-03-20 · claimed 1989-05Inspect the record ↗
  3. Bears onHans MoravecThe Age of Robots1993-06 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  4. Contests · Earliest locatedEliezer S. YudkowskyRe: Hugo de Garis2000-06-22 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  5. ArticulatesHugo de GarisBuilding Gods or Building Our Potential Exterminators?2001-02-26 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  6. ContestsBen GoertzelHugo de Garis2001-05 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  7. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe Artilect War: Cosmists vs. Terrans2005 · published · wording attested 2014-03-17Inspect the record ↗
  8. Bears onKevin WarwickForeword to The Artilect War2005 · published · wording attested 2014-03-17Inspect the record ↗
  9. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe Artilect War: Cosmists vs. Terrans (AGI 2008 paper)2008 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  10. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe Coming Artilect War2009-06-22 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  11. ContestsHugo de Garis; Ben GoertzelSeeking the Sputnik of AGI2011-03-30 · published · wording attested 2015Inspect the record ↗
  12. ContestsBryon PavlackaArtificial General Intelligence and the Future of the Human Race2012 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  13. ArticulatesHugo de GarisHow Will the Artilect War Start?2015-08-10 · published · claimed 2014-01Inspect the record ↗

WB · Scale, direction and cosmic setting of machine intelligence

W05 Superiority by many orders of magnitude

  1. Bears onHans MoravecThe Robot as Liberation from Human Nature1989-12 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31 · claimed 1989-03Inspect the record ↗
  2. Bears onHugo de GarisThe 21st Century Artilect: Moral Dilemmas Concerning the Ultra Intelligent Machine1990 · published · wording attested 1999-03-20 · claimed 1989-05Inspect the record ↗
  3. ArticulatesHans MoravecPigs in Cyberspace1992 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  4. ArticulatesHugo de GarisBuilding Gods or Building Our Potential Exterminators?2001-02-26 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  5. Articulates · Earliest locatedRay KurzweilThe Law of Accelerating Returns2001-03-07 · published · wording attested 2001-11-07Inspect the record ↗
  6. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe Artilect War: Cosmists vs. Terrans2005 · published · wording attested 2014-03-17Inspect the record ↗
  7. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe Artilect War: Cosmists vs. Terrans (AGI 2008 paper)2008 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  8. ArticulatesRay KurzweilKurzweil Responds: Don’t Underestimate the Singularity2011-10-20 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  9. ArticulatesMartin ReesOrganic Intelligence Has No Long-Term Future2015 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  10. Contests · Earliest locatedKevin KellyThe Myth of a Superhuman AI2017-04-27 · publishedInspect the record ↗

W09 Machine intelligence as a physical or cosmic process

  1. ArticulatesHans MoravecToday’s Computers, Intelligent Machines and Our Future1979-02 · published · wording attested 2001-07-10 · claimed 1976-07-21Inspect the record ↗
  2. Bears onHugo de GarisWhat If AI Succeeds? The Rise of the Twenty-First Century Artilect1989 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  3. ArticulatesHans MoravecHuman Culture—A Genetic Takeover Underway1989 · published · wording attested 2001-03-06 · claimed 1988-07Inspect the record ↗
  4. Articulates · Earliest locatedHans MoravecAfter Life1989-09 · published · wording attested 1999-11-10Inspect the record ↗
  5. Bears onNick LandMeltdown1997 · published · wording attested 2004-02-03Inspect the record ↗
  6. ArticulatesHugo de GarisBuilding Gods or Building Our Potential Exterminators?2001-02-26 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  7. ArticulatesRay KurzweilThe Law of Accelerating Returns2001-03-07 · published · wording attested 2001-11-07Inspect the record ↗
  8. ArticulatesHugo de GarisAnswering Fermi's Paradox2001-03-22 · published · wording attested 2015Inspect the record ↗
  9. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe Artilect War: Cosmists vs. Terrans2005 · published · wording attested 2014-03-17Inspect the record ↗
  10. Contests · Earliest locatedPaul G. Allen; Mark GreavesPaul Allen: The Singularity Isn’t Near2011-10-12 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  11. ArticulatesRich SuttonThe AI Singularity: Prospects for Digital Immortality2013-12-03Inspect the record ↗
  12. ArticulatesMartin ReesOrganic Intelligence Has No Long-Term Future2015 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  13. ArticulatesBeff Jezos; bayesNotes on e/acc principles and tenets2022-07-10 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  14. ArticulatesRich SuttonAI Succession2023-07-07Inspect the record ↗

W10 Machine intelligence spreads beyond Earth

  1. ArticulatesHans MoravecToday’s Computers, Intelligent Machines and Our Future1979-02 · published · wording attested 2001-07-10 · claimed 1976-07-21Inspect the record ↗
  2. Articulates · Earliest locatedHugo de GarisWhat If AI Succeeds? The Rise of the Twenty-First Century Artilect1989 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  3. ArticulatesHans MoravecAfter Life1989-09 · published · wording attested 1999-11-10Inspect the record ↗
  4. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe 21st Century Artilect: Moral Dilemmas Concerning the Ultra Intelligent Machine1990 · published · wording attested 1999-03-20 · claimed 1989-05Inspect the record ↗
  5. ArticulatesHans MoravecThe Universal Robot1991-07 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  6. ArticulatesHans MoravecPigs in Cyberspace1992 · published · wording attested 1999-04-27Inspect the record ↗
  7. ArticulatesHans MoravecThe Age of Robots1993-06 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  8. Articulates · Relay of another authorHans MoravecSimulation, Consciousness, Existence1998 · published · wording attested 2000-08-29 · claimed 1996-06Inspect the record ↗
  9. ArticulatesRay KurzweilThe Law of Accelerating Returns2001-03-07 · published · wording attested 2025-01-01Inspect the record ↗
  10. ArticulatesHugo de GarisAnswering Fermi's Paradox2001-03-22 · published · wording attested 2015Inspect the record ↗
  11. ArticulatesHugo de GarisThe Artilect War: Cosmists vs. Terrans2005 · published · wording attested 2014-03-17Inspect the record ↗
  12. ArticulatesMartin ReesOrganic Intelligence Has No Long-Term Future2015 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  13. ArticulatesFrank TiplerAI's Will Save Us All2015 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  14. ArticulatesBeff Jezos; bayesNotes on e/acc principles and tenets2022-07-10 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  15. ArticulatesDaniel FaggellaA Worthy Successor – The Purpose of AGI2023-11-24 · published · wording attested 2024-02-26Inspect the record ↗

WC · Machine intelligence, capital, values and acceleration

W06 Capital or the techno-economic process as machine intelligence

  1. Bears onNick LandCircuitries1992-10 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  2. Articulates · Earliest locatedNick LandMachinic Desire1993 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  3. Bears onHans MoravecThe Age of Robots1993-06 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  4. Articulates · Earliest located use of the name “technocapital” · FictionNick LandMeltdown1997 · published · wording attested 2004-02-03Inspect the record ↗
  5. Bears onOld NickCritique of Transcendental Miserablism2007-01-15 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  6. Bears on · Relay of another authorAlex Williams; Nick Srnicek#ACCELERATE MANIFESTO for an Accelerationist Politics2013-05-14 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  7. ArticulatesNick LandThe Teleological Identity of Capitalism and Artificial Intelligence2014-03-08 · wording attested 2014-03-10Inspect the record ↗
  8. Contests · Earliest locatedReza Negarestani; Robin MackayReengineering Philosophy2018 · published · claimed 2018-11Inspect the record ↗
  9. Bears one/accEffective Accelerationism — e/acc2022-06-01 · published · wording attested 2022-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  10. Bears onBeff Jezos; bayesNotes on e/acc principles and tenets2022-07-10 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  11. Bears onMarc AndreessenThe Techno-Optimist Manifesto2023-10-16 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  12. ArticulatesVincent LêA Conversation with Nick Land (Part 1)2026-01-13 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  13. Contestsjacob (LessWrong user name)Nick Land has no theory of AI, just a theory of capitalism2026-10-09 · publishedInspect the record ↗

W07 The growth of intelligence as its own end

  1. Contests · Earliest located · Earliest located use of the name “orthogonality”Scott AlexanderMeditations On Moloch2014-07-30 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  2. ContestsSteven PinkerThinking Does Not Imply Subjugating2015 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  3. Articulates · Relay of another authorJessica TaylorBook review: Xenosystems2024-09-16 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  4. Bears onJessica TaylorBook review: Xenosystems2024-09-16 · publishedInspect the record ↗

W08 Accelerate rather than restrain

  1. Bears onHans MoravecToday’s Computers, Intelligent Machines and Our Future1979-02 · published · wording attested 2001-07-10 · claimed 1976-07-21Inspect the record ↗
  2. Bears onNick LandMeltdown1997 · published · wording attested 2004-02-03Inspect the record ↗
  3. Contests · Earliest locatedBill JoyWhy the Future Doesn't Need Us2000-04 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  4. Bears onAlex Williams; Nick Srnicek#ACCELERATE MANIFESTO for an Accelerationist Politics2013-05-14 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  5. Articulates · Earliest locatede/accEffective Accelerationism — e/acc2022-06-01 · published · wording attested 2022-06-02Inspect the record ↗
  6. ArticulatesBeff Jezos; bayesNotes on e/acc principles and tenets2022-07-10 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  7. Articulatese/accwhat the f* is e/acc2022-12-26 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  8. ArticulatesMarc AndreessenWhy AI Will Save the World2023-06-06 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  9. Articulates · Earliest located use of the name “accelerationism”Marc AndreessenThe Techno-Optimist Manifesto2023-10-16 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  10. ContestsDaniel FaggellaA Worthy Successor – The Purpose of AGI2023-11-24 · published · wording attested 2026-10-31Inspect the record ↗
  11. ContestsVitalik ButerinMy techno-optimism2023-11-27 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  12. ContestsÉmile P. Torres‘Effective Accelerationism’ and the Pursuit of Cosmic Utopia2023-12-14 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  13. ArticulatesLex Fridman; Guillaume VerdonTranscript for Guillaume Verdon: Beff Jezos, E/acc Movement, Physics, Computation & AGI | Lex Fridman Podcast #4072023-12-30 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  14. ContestsVitalik Buterind/acc: one year later2025-01-05 · publishedInspect the record ↗
  15. Bears onbayesMortals and machines of accelerating scale2026-03-06 · publishedInspect the record ↗